Posted: 19 December 2024 at 12:35am | IP Logged | 2
|
post reply
|
|
The Death of Phoenix is one of the greatest storylines in comics ever! And there have been other hero deaths that also have been very effective. (Although it seems that all the majors--and many minors!--get to die at least once...and then return! I think it's Dr. Strange's turn right now.)
I started this thread specifically to talk about supporting characters--those regular people that inhabit the day to day lives of especially Marvel and DC heroes' secret identities.
Stan Lee made such great use of Aunt May and Peter Parker's very large cast of characters for 100 issues, and other writers after him. When I started reading, the private lives were just as important to me as the super-hero action. I personally really enjoyed the back and forth between Clark Kent and Steve Lombard in my first years reading the Curt Swan era Superman stories.
On the other hand, Stan only gave Iron Man and Daredevil TWO supporting characters each, and it wasn't that great. It took a decade and a half for Frank Miller to fill out Daredevil's life and David Michelinie & co. to do the same for Iron Man.
Steve Gerber was a master of bringing in "regular people" into his stories and making you care for them as much as the heroes. Jack Norris and Richard Rory were two of my favorites, and David Kraft continued their lives--and I appreciated it.
It just seems like bad, lazy writing to kill off Moira McTaggart, Aunt May, Jim Wilson, Betty Ross, Harry Osborn, Jean DeWolff, Sue Dibny, Alexandra DeWitt (Kyle Rayner's girlfriend in the refrigerator), Steve Trevor, Alfred, and many more! Was the death of Gwen Stacy great or awful? There are people on both sides of that argument. (Though Capt. Stacy's death seemed dramatically appropriate.)
Though many were reversed later--I think that just proves that the death decisions were most likely wrong in the first place!
|